Carpenter 158 vs 9310.

9310 or Carpenter 158 Steel: Bolt Finish: Nickel Boron: Caliber: 223/5.56/300 Blackout: Extractor O-ring: Viton; Mil Spec: Carrier Material: 8620 Steel, Toolcraft Proprietary: Carrier Finish: Nickel Boron: Carrier Design: M16 Full Auto Style: Gas Key Material: 4130 Steel: Cam Pin Material: 4140 Steel:Quoted: As I understand it, Carpenter 158 is a case (surface) hardened steel where 8620 is through hardened. This would allow C-158 to be very hard on the outside to prevent wear and crack formation while the inside is softer and more flexible to prevent crack propagation and absorb shock loads. 8620 being through hardened can either be softer ...by comparison to Carpenter 158, AISI 9310 has several elements present in its composition that are detrimental to fatigue while not being evident in the physical properties. It has become evident from the industry that a number of manufacturers have jumped upon the AISI 9310 wagon in order to claim better performance. Firearm Discussion and Resources from AR-15, AK-47, Handguns and more! Buy, Sell, and Trade your Firearms and Gear.

SKU: 5165449729 UPC: 5165449729 MFR#: 5165449729 Nickel Boron Finish Milspec Carpenter No. 158® steel bolt Shot Peened Bolt High pressure tested Mag particle inspected Gas Key Hardened to USGI Specifications Gas Key Grade 8 Hardened Fasteners Gas Key Staked Per Mil-Spec Tool Steel Extractor Extractor Spring Extractor O-ring Insert ToolCraft Logo PA-15 Engraving ToolCraft Premium Carpenter 158 ...

Nov 16, 2013 · Now the bolts, they are made with AISI 9310 Steel, 9310 is better suited for an application such as a M16 bolt. 9310 is a steel typically used for gears, cams and …Friction vs Steel: Dry 0.1: Color: Black: MPI and HPT tested; Tensile strengths of 1550-1600 mpa, or 220,000-235,000 psi. Toughness of over 200 ft./lb. Charpy C-Notch; HRC of 46 yields a 15% increase in hardness at the same toughness comparing to Carpenter 158 & 9310; Mil-Spec Extractor and Ejector Springs, Gas Rings;

Firearm Discussion and Resources from AR-15, AK-47, Handguns and more! Buy, Sell, and Trade your Firearms and Gear.Apr 9, 2021 · If fact, 9310 response to thin section quenching is better that Carpenter 158. And, taking the leap between this statement:". . . by comparison to Carpenter 158, AISI 9310 has several elements present in its composition that are detrimental to fatigue while not being evident in the physical properties . . ." and this statement: It is a super hard finish that runs smooth and is both easy to clean and easy on the wallet. For a comparison of the top 3 black BCG finishes see our article The Best Black BCG Finish - Phosphate vs …Looks like a $10 "premium" for the black nitrate over the phosphorus (both with Carpenter 158 bolts). Don't get me wrong - I'm not trying to "save" ten bucks. Tell me which of these are "better" and that's the one I'll get. Posted ... C158 and 9310, are in high load gears, often in helicopter transmissions, ...

This Toolcraft Bolt is made of Mil-spec Carpenter 158 steel, shot peened, and mag particle inspected. Gas key is chrome lined, phosphate coated, and secured with grade 8 fasteners and staked per mil-spec. Full-auto bolt carrier is phosphate coated and chrome lined. Made in …

Feb 15, 2020 · Carpenter 158 is mil-spec, but many companies nowadays are opting for "stronger" steels like 9310 and S7 which are both tool steels used in large machines. …

The bolt assembly is machined from Carpenter No. 158® steel, shot-peened, MP marked, HP tested, and has a tool steel extractor that is machined from bar stock. Features: - 4340 Extractor spring, mil-spec insert and extractor retainer pin in mag phosphate - Mag phosphate ejector - Mil-spec stainless gas rings - 8620 carrier in FA profile chrome ...Np. The firearmhistory had some great info. I suppose can 9310 be a better bolt material than C158, sure but it has to be heat treated properly in order to do so, and the improvement is less than 8%. So, as always, better make sure you're buying from a reputable manufacturer. I wouldn't pursue a 9310 bolt simply for the sake of having one made out … · 158 Mil Spec which means 158 material is on the TDP but as soon as the next TDP holder submits this material change to 9310 the US Government will accept it, …Jun 26, 2023 ... The steel used is properly hardened, but I don't think it's technically Carpenter 158. However, at under $170, an HPT and MPI-tested BCG is ...Jan 14, 2020 · The Relia-Bolt™ is machined from S7 tool steel and tempered with SRC’s proprietary heat-treating process, significantly increasing strength when compared to MilSpec Carpenter 158. S7 provides a 75% increase in tensile strength, and nearly 60% improvement in yield strength.-See it at Sharps here. Low Plasticity Roller Ball Burnishing: 19. C 158 vs 9310 Bolt. Just ordered a Aero Precision 6.5 bcg with bolt. Bolt is made of 158 carpenter instead of the 9310 i notice most others are. Is the 158 going to hold up fine its …

Dec 10, 2013 · Wilson combat has a 9310 steel Bolt Carrier Group on sale for $98.57, which is something like $70 off regular price. The three main BCGs I am looking at right now: PSA premium 158 Carpenter - was on sale for $109 when I put my order in Rainier Arms 158 Carpenter - on sale for $119 Wilson combat 9310 steel - on sale for $98.57. 9310 Carrier/Bolt Steel. This is superior to 8620. Its development came after the AR15 was originally designed. This steel provides enhanced heat and pressure resistance. The tensile strength is 910 MPa, and the yield strength is 570 MPa. You will sometimes find that 9310 steel is used in the forging of both carrier and bolt. Carpenter …Apr 29, 2017 · Compared to modern alloys, 158 is a very poor choice for carbine weapons, failing in as little as 3,000 rounds when pushed hard - 9310 is far superior in this respect. Continued.... Several have made claims that AISI 9310 has problems. Maybe it does. But it is a fact that 9310 is the most frequently used steel alloy for aircraft gears. Both are alloy steels. Carp. 158 has substantially more chromium and nickel than 8620 which would make it a tougher and more wear resistant steel. Carp 158 is well suited for dies and molds. They are both low carbon steels and need to have carbon added to get the high surface hardness required.HRC of 46 yields a 15% increase in hardness at the same toughness comparing to Carpenter 158 & 9310. Mil-Spec Extractor and Ejector Springs, Gas Rings. While the two bolts have identical construction, the two coatings vary slightly. Here’s the information on both the DLC and NiB-X coatings.As I understand it, Carpenter 158 is a case (surface) hardened steel where 8620 is through hardened. This would allow C-158 to be very hard on the outside to prevent wear and crack formation while the inside is softer and more flexible to prevent crack propagation and absorb shock loads.

Simple, 9310 is an AISI standard grade tool steel which, when properly treated, actually makes it about 7% stronger than “mil-spec” Carpenter 158. The proof is in the numbers. The carrier material, 8620 is used for various aircraft and vehicular applications, has a superior toughness rating, and features solid overall strength properties.

IIRC, the original specifications for the GI issue model were for AQ-9310 (aircraft quality). The bolts were supposed to be good for 75K rounds, but most showed signs of cracking after 50-60K. ... The Carpenter 158 has to be purchased in 20,000 Lb lots and is roughly $5/Lb.The Relia-Bolt™ is machined from S7 tool steel and tempered with SRC’s proprietary heat-treating process, significantly increasing strength when compared to MilSpec Carpenter 158. S7 provides a 75% increase in tensile strength, and nearly 60% improvement in yield strength. Batch MPI and HPT testedIt has been the "Mil-Spec" since. Since the creation of Carpenter 158, the metals industry has continued to innovate, creating new blends of steels. 9310 is a AISI standard grade of tool steel that makes it about ~7% stronger than "mil-spec" Carpenter 158 steels, when appropriately treated.Bolt Carriers made from 8620 Steel, 6A1-4V Titanium or Aluminum; Keys made from 4130 Steel; Bolts available in 9310 Steel or Carpenter 158The Sharps 308 Balanced Bolt Carrier Group Complete has the same innovative design as the Sharps 5.56 Balanced Bolt Carrier Group. The 308 carrier is precisely machined from case-hardened 8620 alloy steel. The 308 Relia-Bolt™ is made of robust 9310 nickel-chrome-moly alloy steel. The entire BCG is finished with DLC …Well, 9310 is actually around 7% stronger than Carpenter 158 and is better than "mil-spec." faxonfirearms.com FWIW, Right To Bear has Toolcraft 9310 BCGs for $80.

The above mentioned 8620 steel is also used by manufacturers to make bolts for certain rifle models. For instance, it was extensively used in World War II for the M1 Garand rifle. Actually, the original M16 rifles also used bolts made of 8620 steel, but the US military found that the bolts were wearing out after 40,000 - 50,000 shots, which is ...

The above mentioned 8620 steel is also used by manufacturers to make bolts for certain rifle models. For instance, it was extensively used in World War II for the M1 Garand rifle. Actually, the original M16 rifles also used bolts made of 8620 steel, but the US military found that the bolts were wearing out after 40,000 - 50,000 shots, which is ...

19. C 158 vs 9310 Bolt. Just ordered a Aero Precision 6.5 bcg with bolt. Bolt is made of 158 carpenter instead of the 9310 i notice most others are. Is the 158 going to hold up fine its …For each property being compared, the top bar is SAE-AISI 4140 steel and the bottom bar is SAE-AISI 9310 steel. SAE-AISI 4140 (SCM440, G41400) Cr-Mo Steel SAE-AISI 9310 (1.6657, G93106) Ni-Cr-Mo Steel. Metric Units US Customary Units. Mechanical Properties. Brinell Hardness: 200 to 310:Available in either 9310 or C158 Steel Bolt. Toolcraft 5.56 NATO Black Nitride Bolt Carrier Group is a Full-Auto M16 BCG manufactured using the finest U.S-sourced raw materials. The Black Nitride coating vastly increases the hardness of the steel, prevents corrosion, is highly resistant to wear, will not flake (it’s not a coating, it’s a ...Bolt Carriers made from 8620 Steel, 6A1-4V Titanium or Aluminum. Keys made from 4130 Steel. Bolts available in 9310 Steel or Carpenter 158. Our products carry a lifetime warranty. Simply put Should any of our products fail, …This Toolcraft Bolt is made of Mil-spec Carpenter 158 steel, shot peened, and mag particle inspected. Gas key is chrome lined, phosphate coated, and secured with grade 8 fasteners and staked per mil-spec. Full-auto bolt carrier is phosphate coated and chrome lined. Made in …kbd512. · #7 · Jun 24, 2014. I believe that the SAE 9310 steel is either slightly superior or slightly inferior to Carpenter 158 steel, in terms of tensile strength. The heat treatment process must be more closely controlled with 9310, from what I've read.16 votes, 32 comments. 263K subscribers in the ar15 community. /r/ar15 is here for your favorite black gun links, build pics, questions and other…Nov 16, 2013 · Now the bolts, they are made with AISI 9310 Steel, 9310 is better suited for an application such as a M16 bolt. 9310 is a steel typically used for gears, cams and things of that nature while Carpenter 158 or P6 tool steel is a plastic injection mold steel. 9310 is easier to machine and is more dimensionally stable in the heat treat process, this equates to better made parts.*The extractors are ... Apr 17, 2019 ... This is typically going to be made of 9310 or Carpenter 158 steel. Bolt Parts: Bolt Body; Gas Rings; Lugs; Extractor; Ejector; Bolt face. Gas ...Can somebody tell me what the difference is between c-158 and 9310 and why 9310 isn't mil-spec? I've seen 9310 used in some bolts and wonder if it's actually inferior. Is there technical data to show that c-158 is superior?On the hardenability of steel, 4140 heat treatment has good strength and good comprehensive mechanical properties, good manufacturability, high yield. The highest temperature is 427 degrees Celsius. 4140 strength, high hardenability, and good toughness, quenching deformation of small, high temperature creep rupture strength, and high.In the case of the M16 family, the US military selected a steel called Carpenter 158 (also known as "C158" or "Car 158") to be used for manufacturing the bolt. Therefore, any AR15 or M16 bolts that claim to follow military specifications (or "mil-spec" for short) should be made of C158 steel as one of the requirements.

HRC of 46 yields a 15% increase in hardness at the same toughness comparing to Carpenter 158 & 9310. Mil-Spec Extractor and Ejector Springs, Gas Rings. Technical Specification. Bolt: S7 Tool steel, …Wilson combat 9310 steel - on sale for $98.57. BCGs are coming down in price and I want to buy a couple of good quality ones while prices are good. I have a Palmetto State Armory premium 158 Carpenter steel bolt carrier group on the way, I ordered it last week for $109. The other BCG I was looking at was the Rainier Arms for $119 and a lifetime ...MPI = Magnetic Particle Inspected. Nitride is my choice over phosphate as it is an actual treatment and it's generally "slicker" and more corrosion resistant. Posted: 11/23/2017 3:40:51 PM EDT. [#2] Toolcraft does not make their own bolts. Just carriers. The bolts they use are top of the line. They offer 158 and 9310.Instagram:https://instagram. kohler official sitevore ekatopfin aquarium heatertransylvania county most wanted The Relia-Bolt™ is machined from S7 tool steel and tempered with SRC’s proprietary heat-treating process, significantly increasing strength when compared to MilSpec Carpenter 158. S7 provides a 75% increase in tensile strength, and nearly 60% improvement in yield strength. Batch MPI and HPT tested tv guide nampa idahoblue horse inmate The most common is Carpenter 158 or C-158 steel, and the second most popular is 9310 steel. The exact difference between them is a lot of scientific talk but the easy version is that 9310-steel is about 7% stronger than C-158 when heat treated correctly. wi weather radar madison Quoted: As I understand it, Carpenter 158 is a case (surface) hardened steel where 8620 is through hardened. This would allow C-158 to be very hard on the outside to prevent wear and crack formation while the inside is softer and more flexible to prevent crack propagation and absorb shock loads. 8620 being through hardened can either be softer ...Looks like a $10 "premium" for the black nitrate over the phosphorus (both with Carpenter 158 bolts). Don't get me wrong - I'm not trying to "save" ten bucks. Tell me which of these are "better" and that's the one I'll get. Posted ... C158 and 9310, are in high load gears, often in helicopter transmissions, ...